Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage – All You Need To Know

Many people overlook important things when selecting which Medicare plan to choose. Since there are many available options, it is easy to get lost in selecting the right Medicare plan for you. It is not just about looking for the lowest premium but also taking into consideration other key factors. Sometimes, choosing more coverage costs money in the present and saves you money down the road.

If you intend to settle for either the Medigap plan or the Medicare Advantage plan, then this article will help you in deciding between which of the two to settle for.

First things first. It is important to understand what the differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage are before discussing Medigap and Medicare Advantage. You need to understand that all these plans are more of an improvement to the Original Medicare Plan.

Original Medicare vs. Medicare Advantage

The similarities between Medicare Advantage and Original Medicare are:

• They both cover inpatient and outpatient treatment
• They both have co-pays, coinsurances, and deductibles
• The coverage plan they both have mimicked an employer-sponsored he
• 
• alth plan

Essentially, you can see that they provide the same coverage that you probably need. As a result, it may be difficult for you to decide which coverage to choose. The differences, pros, and cons will help you with the decision.

The differences between Medicare Advantage and Original Medicare are;

• The Federal government is responsible for administering Original Medicare while Medicare Advantage is administered through private health organizations
• Original Medicare has no maximum out of pocket limit while Medicare Advantage has a maximum out of pocket limit
• Original Medicare does not provide coverage for prescription drugs and routine vision, dental and hearing checkups while Medicare Advantage often does
• Original Medicare is accepted nationwide in places where Medicare is accepted while Medicare Advantage plans have a network.

Pros of Original Medicare

• Nationwide coverage
• The consistency of the benefits of plans
• Medicare Supplement Plan can be added to cover your cost sharing
• There’s no need to assign a primary care physician
• There’s no need to obtain a referral to see a specialist.

Cons of Original Medicare

• No drug coverage
• No routine dental, vision and hearing coverage
• No out of pocket maximum limit which could cause disastrous spending

Pros of Medicare Advantage

• Comes with 0$ or low monthly premium
• Maximum out of pocket limit to curtail dangerous spending
• Includes prescription drug coverage
• Provides additional benefits like routine hearing, vision and dental coverage

Cons of Medicare Advantage

• Limitations of the plan’s network helpful resources
• Annual changes in plan benefits
• The provision of the plan is up to the discretion of the provider who chooses to provide or not
• A Medicare supplement cannot be obtained to offset your cost sharing
• The enrollment, disenrollment and switching of plans is restricted

From these details, you can tell that you can go wrong with any plan you choose. The best option is to pair the Original Medicare plan with a Medigap plan. Otherwise, choosing a Medicare Advantage route means that you have to ensure your prescription needs are covered.

Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage

The information provided above gives the baseline on which to evaluate a decision between a Medigap plan and a Medicare Advantage plan. This is because the pros of the original Medicare plan all apply to the Medigap plan.

The similarities between Medigap and Medicare Advantage are:

• The Part B premium must be paid for both plans
• Both plans are issued by private institutions
• Both plans follow strict regulations set by Medicare
• Both offer a much more comprehensive coverage as compared to Original Medicare

Pros of Medicare Supplement or Medigap

• Nationwide coverage
• Offer a comprehensive solution to cost sharing
• The consistency of the benefits offered by plans
• A primary care physician does not to be assigned
• A referral is not needed in order to see a specialist

Cons of Medigap

• Failure to sign up during Medigap Open Enrollment period means that you will have to pass underwriting and answer health questions to qualify
• More expensive than Medicare advantage
• Excludes prescription drug coverage
• Excludes routine dental, hearing and vision checkups
• No maximum out of pocket limit which can be catastrophic

Pros of Medical Advantage

• Less expensive than Medigap
• Offers additional benefits e.g. Drug prescription coverage
• Easier to qualify
• Available Special Needs Plans designed help people with certain diseases
• Low monthly premiums
• An utmost out of pocket limit

Cons of Medicare Advantage

• Incomprehensive coverage when compared with a plan combining Original Medicare and Medigap
• Higher cost sharing
• Greater deductibles
• Higher co-payment
• Greater co-insurance
• Limitations arising from the specific plan networks
• Rigidity in changing plans, enrollment, and disenrollment due to time restrictions
• Benefits are subject to annual changes
• Provision of the plans is based on the willingness of the provider to either provide or not

With all these cons and pros, what can we conclude?

A Medicare Advantage is a good plan for any of the following people:

1. Those who are in good health and don’t often visit doctors
2. Those who can’t afford the Medigap plan
3. Those who stay within the plan’s network
4. Those who qualify for Special Needs Plan

On the other hand, it is not good for people who:

1. Travel often because they will get out of the plan’s network
2. Are in poor health and use medical services very much
3. Can’t keep up with constant plan changes

The Medigap plan is suitable for a person who:

1. Incurs a lot of out of pocket medical expense through the year
2. Wants a consistent plan
3. Travels often
4. Appreciates changes in the plan to suit their growing health needs

   Conclusion

With all these information, I bet you are better placed to make the right plan decision. You can evaluate yourself based on the pros and cons of each plan and discover which one will suit you better. Don’t experiment with plans when you are certain you will not measure up to the requirements. Choose what is most suitable for you.